Opinion-Policy Nexus

Earlier this week, Danielle Smith failed to win the PC nomination in her riding and the knives were out.  Some commentators and politicians mentioned how "Albertans have spoken" or how "Albertans" didn't like her floor-crossing behaviour and punished her accordingly.

There are a lot of angles to this story but one that hasn't been corrected is this fallacy that Albertans passed judgement on Smith.  Albertans didn't judge Smith.  It was the PC members of Highwood who did that. To say that Albertans didn't like Smith's decision and so Albertans punished her by supporting Carrie Fisher is a little disingenuous.

A better test of Albertan views about Smith would have been if she had won the PC nomination but lost her seat in the upcoming general election. Unfortunately, we won't get a chance to see how that test would have played out.